Why Is the US Demanding Public Social Media for H-1B Visas While Indians Oppose Sanchar Saathi?
A recent update from the United States government has announced expanded screening for H-1B and dependent H-4 applicants starting December 15. The headline condition: applicants must make their social media profiles public for online vetting as part of the national security screening process.
The notice clarifies that visa adjudication is a national security matter, not a right — and the U.S. government expects complete digital transparency. Meanwhile, back home, a curious trend exists: some people refuse to install India’s Sanchar Saathi scam-protection app… because “privacy saar.”
• U.S. mandates public social media for H-1B and H-4 screening
• Applies to F, M, J categories as well
• Screening justified under national security framework
• Visa treated as privilege — not entitlement
• India meanwhile faces resistance over fraud-prevention apps due to “privacy fear”
Ironically, many who reject caller ID verification in India for protecting citizens from fraud… willingly expose their entire digital footprint for a visa interview if the stamp has an eagle printed on it.
That contrast is worth studying — much like understanding sentiment cycles and disruption patterns before executing positions in Nifty Scalping Tip trades.
Global Contrast Table
| Country Action | Public Reaction |
|---|---|
| US → Make all social media public or no visa | “Yes sir. Immediately sir.” |
| India → Install Sanchar Saathi to protect from scams | “Privacy? Fundamental right! Won’t do.” |
Human behaviour rarely follows logic — it follows incentives, fear, and aspiration. And nowhere is this clearer than in immigration, compliance, and digital identity.
|
Strengths
🔹 Strong enforcement clarity |
Weaknesses
🔹 Privacy concerns legitimate |
Data governance globally is shifting — and users now face a new reality: “Transparency for access.”
|
Opportunities
🔹 Safer immigration ecosystem |
Threats
🔹 Surveillance concerns |
Risk management — whether online or in markets — is never about fear. It is about awareness, positioning, and readiness. The same philosophy applies when reading price action on BankNifty Scalping Tip setups.
Mixed reactions aside, one message is clear: the era of digital anonymity in high-mobility, high-compliance ecosystems is fading — fast.
Investor Takeaway
As Certified Derivative Pro Tiger & Nifty Expert Gulshan Khera, CFP®, SEBI-Registered Investment Adviser observes — regulation always evolves ahead of industry maturity. Whether in capital markets or immigration systems, compliance isn’t optional — it becomes the cost of participation.
Related Queries on H-1B and Digital Screening
• Why did the US mandate public social media for visa applicants?
• Is privacy still possible in visa and immigration workflows?
• How does digital vetting affect future compliance rules?
• Will other countries adopt similar models?
• What does this mean for global data governance?
SEBI Disclaimer: The information provided in this post is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as investment advice. Readers must perform their own due diligence and consult a registered investment advisor before making any investment decisions. The views expressed are general in nature and may not suit individual investment objectives or financial situations.
